Black Mamas Spoke, Hospitals Listened: Findings from the Mama Certified Birthing Experience Study

Black mamas in Cincinnati asked for a way to give hospitals direct feedback on their birth experiences. The Mama Certified Birthing Experience Study was designed from this request, giving mamas a voice in shaping better hospital care and holding systems accountable.

251 Black mamas who gave birth at Greater Cincinnati hospitals between September 2024 and December 2025 shared their birth experiences with Mama Certified. Seventeen women participated in additional in-depth interviews, as did fifteen healthcare providers who supported childbirth at a Mama Certified partner hospital.

Where Care is Strongest and Where It Fell Short

Across all four Cincinnati birthing hospital systems, Black mamas rated their care 82 out of 100 on average, and 77% of Black mamas had a score categorized as reflecting optimal or good person-centered care. Being treated with dignity and respect scored the highest, with many mamas feeling like they were treated with respect during their maternity care.

“My maternity and postpartum care were excellent. I felt supported both physically and emotionally, especially during those first challenging weeks.”
— 28-year-old Black mama

Mamas also told us where hospitals fell short: they felt concerns weren’t adequately addressed, received insufficient support during labor and birth, and experienced delays in receiving necessary care. As well, person-centered care experiences varied considerably across hospitals, suggesting that mamas did not consistently receive an optimal experience.

“They talked at me and not to me.”
— 32-year-old Black mama

Three Steps Hospitals Should Take

Black mamas and healthcare providers also shared actions hospitals can take to improve mama’s experiences and outcomes:

Structural Change: Build systems and policies with Black mamas in mind.

Provider Training: Train care teams to listen to and earn mama’s trust.

Patient Power: Ensure mamas have a real voice in every decision about their care.

What Happens Next

Our Queens Village Hospital Advisory Boards, comprised of Black mamas and hospital leaders, will review hospital-specific findings and develop action plans together. Each hospital system — Christ Hospital Network, Mercy Health, TriHealth, and UC Health — has its own board that meets quarterly to co-design and implement improvement projects.

Read the full report to see what mamas said and steps hospitals should consider on their journey of providing more equitable care.

Every Story Shapes Better Care

The Birthing Experience Survey is how Black mamas tell Mama Certified, in their own words, whether they felt heard, respected and involved in decisions about their care. Queens Village Hospital Advisory Boards use these results to design hospital improvement projects.

The survey is open now through December 31, 2026. Please share this link with every eligible mama you serve.

Next
Next

Meet Our 2026 Champions for Change Winners